OPEN LETTER TO Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez from Mansoor Hussain Laghari on LinkedIn.com:
Congresswoman Ocasio-Cortez,
You chose Germany to use the word genocide against Israel.
Germany.
The country where genocide was engineered with bureaucratic precision. The land where six million Jews were industrially exterminated. The soil where memory is not symbolic but sacred.
That word is not casual there. It is seismic.
Genocide is a legal term under international law. It requires specific intent to eliminate a people. It is not defined by civilian casualties alone. It is defined by deliberate destruction of an ethnic or religious group.
On October 7, Israel was attacked in the deadliest massacre of Jews since the Holocaust. Civilians were slaughtered. Women were brutalized. Families were burned. Children were kidnapped. Hostages were dragged into underground tunnels.
That was not “context.”
That was the beginning of the war.
Hamas embeds its military infrastructure inside civilian neighborhoods. It stores weapons in schools. It builds tunnels beneath homes and hospitals. It uses women and children as shields.
This is not rhetoric. It is documented asymmetric warfare.
Yes, civilian suffering in Gaza is real. Every innocent life lost is a tragedy. But tragedy is not automatically genocide. War in dense urban terrain against an entrenched terrorist organization is not legally synonymous with the systematic intent to destroy a people.
When an American member of Congress stands in Germany and labels Israel’s self-defense as genocide, the consequences are profound:
You legitimize a narrative that fuels antisemitism globally.
You embolden extremists who chant for the elimination of Israel.
You dilute the historical meaning of genocide itself.
You fracture the moral clarity young Americans desperately need.
Criticism of Israeli policy is legitimate. Democracies must withstand scrutiny. But equating self-defense against a terrorist organization with genocide is not precision. It is escalation.
New York is home to the largest Jewish population outside Israel. Your words do not remain in Berlin. They echo in synagogues, on campuses, and in streets where antisemitic incidents are already rising.
Leadership is not about amplifying the loudest crowd. It is about speaking hard truths even when your base resists them.
Terrorism is wrong.
Hostage-taking is wrong.
Antisemitism is wrong.
No qualifiers. No footnotes.
History has a long memory, especially in Germany.
This post does not promote hate; it is meant to inform and encourage respectful discussion. We stand against antisemitism in all forms.
No comments:
Post a Comment